Walking into a classic dining room after a day on mountain trails creates an appetite for something genuine, and when guests sit down for dinner here at our Gatlinburg restaurant, they encounter a our tradition of cutting your steak to your specifications at the tableside. At The Peddler Steakhouse, this method has anchored our dining room on the Little Pigeon River for generations. Read on to find out more about the custom cut steak at our Gatlinburg restaurant and why it is so popular among our guests!
What Does Custom Cut Steak Mean?
A custom cut steak is a fresh portion of beef that is selected and sliced to a guest's preferred thickness directly at the table. Rather than receiving a pre-portioned steak cut hours earlier in a back kitchen, you choose the exact cut, marbling, and weight before it ever touches the grill! While most commercial kitchens rely on pre-packaged, frozen, or factory-portioned cuts, our tableside approach allows you to inspect the raw loin in person. You can view the natural fat distribution and decide exactly how hearty your dinner should be.
The Tradition of Tableside Steak Cutting

Our restaurant opened its doors in Gatlinburg in 1976. Over the years, tableside steak cutting became the centerpiece of our guest experience, as we believe that dinner should be an interactive event where family members share stories and participate in their meal. First, one of our skilled steak peddlers rolls a custom dining cart directly to your table, which displays whole loins of quality beef. You can then talk directly with the peddler about how much you want to eat and how you like your steak grilled, which creates a personal interaction that turns an ordinary dinner into a lasting memory. Over four decades later, guests who visited us as children now bring their own kids to experience the very same tableside tradition!
How Do You Choose a Steak Size at The Peddler?
To choose a steak size at The Peddler, you simply guide the steak peddler as they present a whole loin at your table. You indicate where to slice the meat based on your preferred thickness or target weight in ounces, giving you complete control over your dinner portion. Many diners wonder how much steak they should order. Here is the simple step-by-step process that our guests follow:
- Review the cut selection: Consider whether you prefer a rich, marbled ribeye or a firmer, lean New York strip.
- Inspect the loin tableside: Your steak peddler displays the full loin so you can see the grain and marbling up close.
- Set your cut line: Point to your desired thickness. The peddler will estimate the weight in ounces before slicing.
- Confirm your cut: Once sliced, the cut is weighed to give you the exact size and price for your meal.
Every custom-cut entrée also includes full access to our fresh salad bar, and families love pairing their hand-carved entrée with crisp greens and scratch-made dressings!
Is Ribeye or New York Strip Better for Custom Cutting?

Both ribeye and New York strip are ideal for custom cutting, but they satisfy different personal tastes. A ribeye features richer intramuscular fat, while a New York strip offers a tighter grain with a firm chew. Choosing between them depends on how you balance tenderness, fat content, and grilling style. Understanding these two cuts helps you make an informed choice at your table:
- Ribeye Steak: Cut from the beef rib primal, this cut contains generous ribbons of internal fat. As it cooks over hickory coals, that fat melts to baste the meat from within, delivering rich flavor.
- New York Strip: Cut from the short loin, this steak features a dense texture and a distinct fat cap along its edge. It offers robust beef flavor without heavy internal pockets of fat.
Why Steak Thickness Matters for Doneness
Steak thickness directly controls how heat travels from the grill surface into the center of the meat. A thin steak has the potential to overcook in the middle before developing a proper charred crust, while a thicker custom cut lets our grill masters achieve deep sear on the outside while keeping the center tender and juicy. When you request a thick cut, you give the steak room to rest after grilling, which allows hot juices to redistribute evenly through the meat, ensuring every bite is rich and tender.
Where Is the Best Place to Eat Near the Smoky Mountains Entrance?

One of the best places to eat near the Smoky Mountains entrance is The Peddler Steakhouse at 820 River Road in downtown Gatlinburg. We are located just minutes from the national park boundary, and our dining room sits directly on the banks of the Little Pigeon River, offering relaxing water views after a long day outdoors. Our location combines scenic natural beauty with easy walking access to downtown parkway shops. As a beloved riverside steakhouse in Gatlinburg, we pride ourselves on giving every guest a warm welcome. We also offer dedicated options on our children's menu at The Peddler so younger guests feel right at home!
Plan Your Visit to The Peddler Steakhouse
Ready to join us on River Road to enjoy tender custom-cut steaks, a fresh salad bar, and serene water views on your next mountain getaway? We would love to welcome you! Go ahead and make your reservation at our Gatlinburg restaurant right here to ensure that a table is ready for your next visit.









